Whores, Hoglegs, and Whiskey
Elijah had the misfortune of stumblin right into the party right after they had butchered a bunch of cultists and were feeling mighty untrusting. The poor sheriff had his head blown open from a shot by Markus G. Hearts, was trampled by Nephi Sackett’s horse, and then some how rose from the dead and was killed yet again.
As if this wasn’t enough, the good sheriffs clothing was taken as it was somehow… less bloody than what Nephi was wearing after having the sheriffs head explode all over him.
The party lied to Penny about having any knowledge of the sheriffs murder and she firmly believes them due to the circumstances she witnessed at the Lalaurie house.